, pub-3297679548843483, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0 site-verification: b639df4d151cb0afd311c230e6c9019c
top of page

NYC Historic Penthouse Owned By Judge Judy Lists For $9.5M, See Inside!

Experience the epitome of refined living in this exquisite duplex penthouse at Sutton Place South. Situated within one of Sutton Place's superior pre-war white glove cooperatives, this superbly renovated residence offers 4-bedrooms, 4-bathrooms, and 2 half-bathrooms. Boasting panoramic exposures and an expansive wrap-around terrace, this sun-kissed aerie is one of the crown jewels of this tony enclave. Upon entry from the semi-private elevator landing, an impressive 29-foot entrance gallery leads to spacious, welcoming rooms, perfect for entertaining. The commodious living room, featuring a wood-burning fireplace and breathtaking east and south-facing views of the East River, sets the stage for elegant gatherings. The formal dining room, adorned with floor-to-ceiling French casement doors, offers an exquisite setting for hosting guests. The paneled library, with a second wood-burning fireplace, is a warm and comfortable retreat. The chef's kitchen, appointed with professional-grade appliances and an abundance of space, doubles as a social hub and casual dining area. The expansive wrap-around terrace, accessible from the living room, dining room, and library, presents stunning city and river views. With two dining areas and lounge seating surrounded by lush, mature plantings, it's the perfect setting for alfresco entertaining. A stately curved staircase with its original wrought iron balustrade leads to the lower level, where the beautifully proportioned corner primary bedroom awaits, offering views of the East River, a spacious en-suite bath, and plenty of closet space. Three additional generously sized bedrooms, two with en-suite baths and one with an adjacent hall bathroom, provide comfort and privacy. This sun-flooded home boasts central air conditioning, an integrated sound system, high ceilings, and traditional moldings. Designed by renowned architect Rosario Candela in 1929, 14 Sutton Place South also offers a full-time doorman, a resident manager, gym, bikeroom and a deeded private storage unit. Pets, pieds-a-terre, and 50% financing are permitted. There is a 2.5% flip tax. Indulge in an unparalleled lifestyle at this exceptional Sutton Place residence, where elegance and sophistication converge to create an extraordinary living experience.

Listing by:

Compass 917-543-0005,

Tom Postilio - Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Property Information:


14 Sutton Pl S #A, New York, NY 10022

4 beds

6 baths


2,096 views0 comments


bottom of page